Ableton Suite 8 upgrade vs full Melodyne Editor

If you won a prize and could choose a boxed upgrade to Suite 8 or the full boxed version of Melodyne’s Editor which would you choose?

They are completely different. Its like an apples to oranges comparison.

Yeah, I know…but it is a prize :wink:



I guess what I’m really asking is out of the two, which would I use most of the features?



Personally I might use Melodyne more because I already have AU/VSTs that sound better than a lot of the features in Suite.

I have both, and for what its worth I almost never use Melodyne.



Not for any real reason, just it’s best suited for vocals and some sampled instruments, and I’ve not had need/occasion to use it much.



Suite on the other hand has loads of really good and really useful things. So I guess, if it were me, and I just had vanilla ableton, I might go for suite.

What Bang said…

What Howie said that Bang said

What Howie and Bang and Slender said.

so what would happen if i recanted and said i was wrong?


Simple - if you work with a lot of live audio or vocals then Melodyne.

Otherwise go 4 suite - I use Sampler and Operator all the time.

[quote]howiegroove (21/02/2011)[hr]so what would happen if i recanted and said i was wrong?[/quote]



But Howie your never wrong :stuck_out_tongue:

What Howie and Bang and Slender and TheAnt said.

LOL



I’m not sure what was said now :wink:

[quote]slender (21/02/2011)[hr][quote]howiegroove (21/02/2011)[hr]so what would happen if i recanted and said i was wrong?[/quote]



But Howie your never wrong :P[/quote]



I forgot…sorry! :smiley: